“Merlot BellaVitano (5.3 oz.) – Sartori” has been added to your cart. View cart

“Shire (4 oz.) – Lively Run Dairy” has been added to your cart. View cart

“A2A2 Natural Flavor Fresh Cheese Curd Made with Whole Milk (8.0 oz.) – Next Generation Creamery” has been added to your cart. View cart

“Balsamic BellaVitano (5.3 oz.) – Sartori” has been added to your cart. View cart

“Cranberry Jack Cheese (8 oz.) – Shtayburne Farm” has been added to your cart. View cart

“Pecorino Romano DOP (7 oz. avg.) – Locatelli” has been added to your cart. View cart

Adams Reserve (32 oz.), NY Extra Sharp Cheddar

Closeup of a block of Adams Reserve, unwrapped.

A closeup view of a 2 lb. package of Adams Reserve NY Extra Sharp Cheddar.

Adams Reserve (32 oz.), NY Extra Sharp Cheddar

Name: Adams Reserve (32 oz.), NY Extra Sharp Cheddar
Brand: Great Lakes Cheese
SKU: C0374
Availability: InStock
Rating: 5.00 (4 reviews)

(4 customer reviews)

$14.99 Prices in-store may be different from those on our website.

A 2 pound block of extra sharp New York Cheddar cheese, naturally aged over 12 months. World Championship Cheese Contest winner!

Adams Reserve (32 oz.), NY Extra Sharp Cheddar

A 2 pound block of extra sharp New York Cheddar cheese, naturally aged over 12 months. World Championship Cheese Contest winner!

The ultimate hometown favorite, Adams Reserve is named after (and made) right here in Adams, NY at the Great Lakes Cheese plant! It also doesn't hurt that it's some of the best tasting cheddar we've ever had…

New York Cheddar has a bit more of an acidic bite to it than other domestic cheddars, and the texture can often by slightly softer.

Each brick of Adams Reserve NY Extra Sharp Cheddar cheese weighs 32 oz.

Frequently Bought Together

A jar of Red Apple Orchards apple butter.

$5.69Add to cart

4 reviews for Adams Reserve (32 oz.), NY Extra Sharp Cheddar

Carol (verified owner) – May 26, 2023

My favorite cheddar
Cheryl Monden – March 26, 2023

Makes the absolute BEST Macaroni and cheese dish ever. My family and friends call it CrackMac!!!
NANCY SMITH – February 28, 2023

Love that cheese. My local ShopRite doesn’t seem to carry the 2 pound block anymore. Will have to check other markets.
Daniel L Daum – December 11, 2022

My nephew … works for [Great Lakes Cheeese] and encouraged me to try it…..probably the best cheese I’ve ever tasted.